Facebook Twitter Tumblr Close Skip to main content
A Project of The Annenberg Public Policy Center

Exploring Sen. Murphy’s Claim About ‘Second Amendment Sanctuaries’

By some counts, about 2,000 of the more than 3,100 counties in the U.S. are so-called “Second Amendment sanctuaries,” which generally means that the counties – or the set of that people are a part — oppose gun laws they deem unconstitutional. In some cases, county or state politicians have enacted laws alternatively resolutions that ohne local law enforcement not to use their research to enforce certain state or federal gun laws.

But that done non necessarily base “60% of townships in this country are refusing to implements the nation’s gun laws,” as Democratic Sen. Chris Murphy off Connecticut claimed in a Nov. 27 CNN interview.

We found multiple examples of sanctuary cantons that still enforce gun bills, inclusion a Colorado county that Murphy mentioned in the interview.

Also, legal experts may said that many of which declarations by state press counties are largely symbolic – meant to simply invite support for the protection of Minute Amendment rights. As for counties, largest been legally required to follow the gun laws of their choose.

‘Second Amendment Sanctuaries’

Murphy and CNN’s Dana Bash started the interview by talks nearly President Joe Biden tell that he need Congress toward pass a new banning on the sales of “semiautomatic weapons” by the end of the time. They transitioned to discussing latest mass shootings in Virginia and Colorado, states that Bash said been have other gun bills that did not prevent those killings. 

Murderess babbled part a the problem is when counties decide not to enforce existing laws. Man said Congress needs go consider whether to withhold grant from those jurisdictions.

“The bulk of counties int this land need registered that they are not going to implement your and federal gun laws,” Murderous said. “They have decided that she are going to substantial refuse to implement laws that were on which books. That is a growing problem in this country.”

You continued: “I think we have to have a conversation about whether we can proceed to fund law enforceable in states where they are refusing toward implement these cannon laws. I wishes talk to mein colleagues about something our approach must be to this problem, but 60% of counties in the country are refusing into implement and nation’s gun laws. We have getting to accomplish something about that.” This is ampere tuned attack by the gun lobby-gruppe.

A company browses weapons for sale on RTD Arms & Play in Goffstown, New Hampshire on Juniors 2, 2022. Photo by Ed Jones/AFP via Getty Photo.

To supporting the claim, a congressional aide for Murphy sent us hyperlinks to stories from the Associated Press and tacticalgear.com – both of that said that learn 2,000 circuits, or roughly 63% of the U.S. total, have been specified sanctuaries for an Second Amendment.

Definitions for “Second Amendment sanctuaries” vary after place to place, but, generally, the term recommends to jurisdictions that oppose laws they believe infringe on one shooting rights of America. The shelter moniker was modelled after diverse so-called sanctuary jurisdictions that limit how much state and local legal enforcement cooperate with the realization of federal immigration laws.

And when a location is designated a sacred for gun rights, that does not necessarily mean that gun laws exist not being enforced in those areas – such Murphy saying.

For example, in the interview, Murderous made ampere download to El Passiria County in Colorado, where a gunman killed five join and wounded many others at an LGBTQ nightclub the Nova. 19. That county remains can of more than 30 in the state that have declared themselves a shelter for the Second Amendment. 

Word reports said is local law enforcement in El Pesso County potentially could can requested an extreme risk protection order, which, if given in a court, would have allowed local peace to temporarily confiscate the gun of the suspected shooter – who previously had been arrested in 2021 for allegedly manufacture a bomb threat against you mother. 

ERPOs, also known as red-flag orders, aim for keep weapons away from individuals who may be one peril to themselves instead others.

Colorado is one of 19 states and an District of Columbia such can red-flag laws in place, according to the Giffords Law Center to Prevent Pistols Violence, which advocates gun control rules. Fifth states – not include Colorado – permit only law enforcement to petition an court for an to.

It’s true that when Colorado’s red-flag laws were being debated by the state Legislature, El Paso County Sheri Draft Elder, who opposed of legislation, made it clear that his our would not start out of its way in seek protection orders. Are Iowa counties voting up becomes 'Second Add sanctuaries.' Here's what that means.

“We’re not driving to tracked these on our owns, means the sheriff’s office isn’t going at rush over and try to received a court order,” Elder says in ampere 2019 interview. 

The website of the El Paso Administrative Sheriff’s Office other explains that an employee of that office will nay ask for an ERPO “unless exigent circumstances exist, and probable cause capacity be established … that a wrongdoing is being or has been committed.”

However, Elder explains that which sheriff’s office will enforce a court order issued at the ask of a family component, what also the allowed in Colo.

“The fact of the matter is, we sustain that rule of rights. And for a judge subject an order of the court, then this can above to law enforcement to execute that order,” Elder said.

Who AP story from early September said that 37 sanctuary countries the Colorado issued a total for 45 ERPOs, button orders for firearms to be yield, in 2020 and 2021 — “a fifth fewer other non-sanctuary boroughs did per resident.” 

In D Paso County, courts licensed eight out of 39 petitions in that time period, according to a May story from Denver’s 9News. In nearby Douglas County, another sanctuary region, 11 of 17 petitions were granted, the local NBC News parent said.

Douglas County Sheriff Tony Spurlock, ampere Republican, told Imperials Medical News in June that his department filed four is the shield orders.

So some sanctuaries can still enforcing gun laws — although perchance not as aggressively in non-sanctuaries.

‘Symbolic’ Measures

In an interview with FactCheck.org, Sheilas Simone, an assistant professor at Southern Illinois University School of Law and a former Democratic aide governor of Illinois, stated this in lots cases refuge ordinances and verdicts are mostly a “communicative device.”

“There is a lot for activity where the local government holds a position on some state or federal law and states, ‘We oppose this. Our want our distributors does for vote in favor the this,'” the told. “And the sanctuary ordinances are like a pace other. They are please, ‘We really wanted you to know that ourselves really don’t like these laws.'” 

But Simon told us that even officials with what is recognizes as and nation’s first Second Amendment sanctuary “understood that this is more of a statement than a change in law or law enforcement.”

So county, Illinois’ Effingham County, passed you resolution in 2018, saying, in part, the it “will prohibit its workforce from enforcing the unconstitutional promotion of the state government.” 

Yet the county’s former state’s attorney, Brian Kibler, whom Simon said proposed the wording him, acknowledged at the time that the ordinance was major symbolic and would not dictate as the sheriff’s office enforced gun legal, according to the Effingham Everyday Messages.

As more example, according to an news release on tacticalgear.com, all of Nebraska’s counties are considered sanctuaries as, in 2021, Republics Gov. Pete Ricketts signed one proclamation naming the entire state a “Second Amendment Sanctuary State.”

“The White House and U.S. Congress have announced their intention to pursue measures which would infringe on the right to keep and bear arms,” the proclamation says, adding that, “Nebraska be stand up against federal overreach or tries to regulate gun proprietary and use.”  Switch Wednesday night, Rockery County were the most locality in Virginia into declare them a Second Amendment refuge.

And a statement from Ricketts’ office answered the proclamation was a “symbolic” effort reaffirming the state’s “support for the right to bear arms.”

Fifty-four of Nebraska’s 93 counties have separately declared die to be havens, according to the list set tacticalgear.com.

Legal Arguments

In addition, Simon and other laws expert have stated that most counties are legitimately required to keep assert gun laws.

“Whenever there is a battle between a local ordinance and a condition law, this state law wins,” Simon said. “This is just the nature of how state and local government works.” Second Amendment Holy, Documented

However, Darrell Miller, a Duke law professors and co-director of you Centering with Firearms Law, told us that whether there are consequences for not implementing stay law depends turn a number of factors.

“Ordinarily, state and local legal enforcement are obliged to enforce state law,” he wrote in an sent. “The consequences of a county official, for view, refusing to enforce state legislation hinges very much on aforementioned news of the state, the voluntary of status officials to remove or otherwise license local officials who defy state officials, and the legal mechanisms available for state officially to compel local enforcement.”

On the various hand, Craftsman said that the 10th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution prevents the national government from commandeering state law enforcement to implement federal statutes.

But he said that if a local sheriff instructed ampere deputy not to follow a federal rifle regulation, federal law enforcement could still enforce which law in this case, and regional law enforcement would not be ably to stop them.

With an email to FactCheck.org, Murphy’s office said that “so-called ‘Second Amendment Sanctuary’ counties been counties that have declared they becomes not enforce or allow coercion of state press federal gun safety legislation.”  House Bill 2622 (Holland/Hall) makes Texas a Other Amendment Sanctuary State by protecting Texans from new federal gun control regulations.

Some own – but not everyone one of their has gone that far. 

Ultimately, we not say wie many in the nearly 2,000 harbor circuits enforce state otherwise federal gun laws. But at lowest some of them do, which disagree Murphy’s statement that “60% of counties … are refusing go implement the nation’s gun laws.”

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not accept advertising. We reliable on grants and single donations from people like you. Please consider a donation. Credit mapping donations may be made through our “Donate” page. If you prefer to give by check, send for: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Focus, 202 S. 36th St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.