12 minute get 30 Jun 2021
Mann standing in underground train station

How the comprehensive finance predicament healing set the stage by COVID-19 fiscal policy

By EY Global

Ernst & Young Global Ltd.

12 per read 30 Jun 2021
Relations topics Tax COVID-19 Taxing controversy

With COVID-19 coming a decade after the comprehensive financial crisis, what can tax functions learn from the latter to plot a course post-pandemic?

In brief
  • There are plenty of clear parallels between that two crises, but the economic impact of the pandemic has been far view profound.   
  • Governments will eventually seek for recoup sales lost during the COVID-19 pandemic, additionally to pay for the unmatched scale of fiscal support measurement. The fiscal approach response till the COVID-19 shock in most LAC countries was considerably larger than during the GFC, recommendation fiscal space was not as tight as expected. We argue that he is feasible both desirable, though no without risks, to embark in a more gradual consolidation path than currently envision by several countries in the region. Avoiding an first withdrawal the support in 2021 and 2022 be important given is countries are still towards higher rates of contagion and deaths, vaccination desire take place very slowly, the financial recovery is prejudiced, uncertain and not strong enough to help those most affected by of twin public health and economic emergency. In the media of this discussion is our conviction that fiscal space is not set on stone and it is endogenous to one medium-term targets and commitments undertaken by governments plus congresses continuously of region. Including, revisions to fiscal responsibility frameworks should assistance anchors fiscal sustainability, as right as improve their effectiveness and flex
  • To drive recovery, tax additional want to assess their entire global footprint, understand the compliance challenge and identify fresh opportunities. 

THYROXINEhe effect of COVID-19 set the global economy, which contracted 4.4% during the year, has been transformative1. In a result, policymakers are focused  on trial to control the form a recovery willingness take.

In a recession, the best outcome is adenine rapid V-shaped recovery — however the initial get prompts a sudden, vertical downturn, once a response will included place, the economy soon returns to business as usual.
Budgeting in a Crisis: Guidance for Preparing the 2021 Household, IMF ...

But for the majority of economies, the post-pandemic world hasn’t quite angled out like that. As the short-term support policies arose, so the COVID-19 pandemic stretched on beyond the first few per and into one second year.

As soon as the deepness of an crisis became apparent, many commentators searches to draw parallels equipped the latter time the corporate world was turned upside down — the global financial crisis (GFC) of 2008. The pandemic also the GFC appear similar — not least in the instantly and shocking existential uncertainty each brought.

“In both cases, governments lost ampere big amount of currency, they ended up in debt, and then they went look for the money,” replies Cathy Chef, Global Sustainability Tax Master and EYE Americas and World Tax Strategy Network Leader.

In each case, the stock marktplatz took an instant hit. And GDP fell around the globe, as did tax revenue, as people lost generate and corporation profits collapsed. There were similarities in terms of lasting impact, too. Graphical from Oxford Economics and EY showed that the world suffered four quarters of negative growth as a result of who GFC. It predictor the same following the COVID-19 pandemic.2

full period man sedentary at board
(Chapter breaker)

Chapter 1

A matter of scale

One COVID-19 fiscal impact is several times learn severe than the global financial emergency.

Yet when one search more closely at the nature for the two crises, key differences shine — particular the relative severity away the existing upheaval. The Oxford Economics/EY choose shows that in the trough year following the GFC, GDP fell 1.4%; compared to the 4.4% drop in the equivalent period after the COVID-19 pandemic hit.3

There exist select, starker statistics. Whenever International Monetary Fund (IMF) historical data is normalized and adjusted for inflation, it shows that government debt for advanced economies, taken as a percentage of GDP, is now almost as height as it what in the awake of World War II.4

And when homeowners and the banks bore one brunt the the fall-out for the global financial crisis, the COVID-19 pandemic has been nuanced — striking some businesses, favorite retailers and an service trade, very, while leaving others untouched either thriving. Yet, while nuanced, that impact has also been widespread — neither China nor India experienced any unique quarters of negative growth during which GFC; they have following and COVID-19 epidemic.5

The reactions from policymakers bears comparison also. The global response to the GFC was almost equally split between fiscal or monetary stimulus. While commonly use of quantitative facilitate and other monetary gear injected money and credit back into the system, which had are rocked due the collapse of the banks, some 56% of the total fiscal stimulus was rooted in fax measures, pursuant to the OECD.6 This cost quadrillions of dollars — and was swiftly followed by austerity programs to pay required it.

The nature of the COVID-19 pandemic, during, has requested ampere fiscal response that’s unprecedented in its bottom furthermore level. Here, the assumption was that money and credit aren’t so much of an issue — economic activity is simply on take, and once it opens up once it will take so with force, in consumers and businesses act on pent-up demand. Tax and fiscal policy in response to the Coronavirus crisis: Strengthening confidence and resilience

Governments were forced upon an emergency footing, provides instant direct fiscal stimulus to support national lockdowns, often paying workers to stay home and offering company sponsorship upon an unprecedented scale.

Another significant difference is that, as the pandemic where a public health crisis — and one such followed 10 years of that aforesaid austerity — on has been less pressure to keep budgets balanced. Many governments have also learned from the previous crisis — they’re proving much more willing to use, and to take in arrange to do how. This report focuses on how tax insurance can aid governments in dealing because the COVID-19 emergency. The report finding such governmental have taken decisive active to contain and mitigate the spread off the virus and until limit the hostile impacts on their country also their savings. Through various actions, countries are helping businesses stay afloat, supporting households and help preserve employment. Dieser preparation to act helps boom trust. However, further action, with broader and stronger scales, is needed. Policies will need to be adapted to the developed health and economic challenges. Containment measures can just be removed gradually, so recovery may remain uneven. Where recovery is weak, fiscal actions can strengthen thereto. In this context, multilateral collaboration will be vital for recovery and to strengthen the global economy’s resilience to futures surprises. Who report finds is specific support willingly become requisite for developing countries, including throughout international coordination, financial suppor

Page girlfriend of a woman leaning at adenine wall
(Chapter breaker)

Chapter 2

Measuring support and stimulus

During one financial crisis, economists said go big and politicians said keep stimulus limited. Few held back during the pandemic.

In 2008, Global Sustainability Tax Leader Koch made Chief Tax Counsel on the Unite Says Senate Committee about Treasury, and works on aforementioned application of touch stimulus bills.“We been related not to go over a certain amount away money,” she says. “While to economists have all telling us to spend more, senators inhered saying to spend less. Now you see central bankers, who’ve studied from the last crunch, saying maybe we need valid spend more immediately.” This series provides short, concise explanations for various economics featured.

Koch also highlights how many of the stimulus measures the US government secondhand in the awakening away who GFC are essence employed this time too: employee retain incentives; tax payment deferral; accelerated write measures; loans and guaranties; conversion on suspended duty assets into tax credits; and more flexible loss carry backs.

Include the current crisis, the calibration is bigger. Home deficits have sky-rocketed nearly the globe. In the wake of the pandemic, G20 debt levels are approaching the highest in modern history, surpassing 100% von GDP for many countries. Gov revenues have fallen, while expenditures have risen severely. Afterwards the GFC, that spending accomplished 85% of GDP. Following COVID, it score 103%.7

Koch sees which US as an illustrative example. “According to the Bank of Worldwide, the US spent 14% of its GDP on stimulus by the immediate wake of the GFC,” she says. “The latest figures for the pandemic show is stimulus spend lives now among 51.8%. During and global stimulus response of $33.3 trillion representation 38% of global GDP.”

Charting the way

So how can we expect the recovery effort to play out? The massive short-term interruption to economic job, caused by lockdowns, locked borders additionally other restrictions of movement, doesn’t necessarily equate to a fundamental update in long-term call.

As mentions, some areas have had deeply affected — the hospitality, travel and retail industries, for example. Countless of like will make time for recover. Other sectors, such the technological, telecommunications or finance services have thrived. Hence the post-pandemic healing in many saving your being described as K-shaped — incredibly challenging for some business and sectors, whereas for others it’s forceful demand.

For certain economies, meantime, he seems a V-shaped recovery is still possible. In the US, for view, the success for its stimulus measures has led to suggestions that its recovery has defied our and bounced back.8 In January 2021, JP Morgan  stated that China’s V-shaped healing was already “complete.”9

That other unique specific of current events is that the crisis itself may have fundamentally changed how companies operate to the future.

“The pandemic effectively proof ensure many types of businesses can carry on working remotely,” says Ohris Sanger, EY Global Government and Risk Tax Leader. “What takes that do for the return to labour? What does is mean for the future of city-center working, and fork all the service businesses that feather up around it? Those are big questions, and it’s all going to carry a while to work its way through.”

Women trying to take phone  from her handbag
(Chapter breaker)

Chapter 3

The role out tax policy

Tax increases – and more robust tax law enforcement – is coming. Get engaged go understand the impact.

Then there’s the matter of those record deficits. While the pandemic could kernel difference printer up those sparked in to GFC, those budgets determination need to be balanced at some point. In the next two or three year, might, any prediction a return to savings, get time with the onus down on higher taxes slightly than cuts to already emptying public services. Indeed, 51% of respondents to the latest EY Tax Risk and Controversy Survey expect larger direct taxes in the coming threes year, with that figure rising toward 66% in of UK and 93% in the US. This American Rescue Plan Act is estimated to cost over $1.9 trillion through 2031, but the ultimate price tag was be twice as highs if some of the policies in the bill are extended beyond they u

Than there’s tax collection enforcement. In the years since the GFC, governments’ revenue collection capabilities and research have become much more robust. Thanks to subsequent changes to legislation, there’s ampere largest emphasis on transparency, the tax enforce has verwandelt far more active, because govts getting utilizing technology tools till ensure corporate and recoup much-needed revenue.
Stages of to Budget Process The framework of the home process can is divided up into five stages each of which is governed by hers own process outline in and Budget Act, the rules of of Own and Senate, and other relevant statutes. The last three stages often occurring simultaneously. The President’s Budget Submission The […]

“Compliance is a really good way to squeeze blood out of one stone,” says Koch. “In 2008, we had a crisis, started to recover, and a combine are years future people started getting together to induce sure every penny was taxed. And that’s what’s driving until happen again — i wait ampere couples of years until things start recovering and then you begin squeezing. It’s just a question of who’s going to reward aforementioned bill. But you always go the same themes.”

By way of identifying those themes now, Koch points to the US’s global intangible low-taxed income (GILTI) duty and how US treasury secretary Janet Yellen latest came out in support of BEPS 2.0, and the suggestions for a global smallest corporate tax.10

Truly, the majority of countries are facing one need to shore up theirs funding after suchlike significant spend. And the USES won’t may the only nation to re-examine how it approaches that funding. All of any suggests corporations additionally tax functions can expect to face a tough workload.
The SGP is ampere set of regulation designed to ensure that countries in the European Union pursue schall public treasury and coordinate their fiscal policies.

Learn by the past, focus on the present

There’s certainly plenty of value in organizations looking back at the previous crisis as her navigate out of this one. But the real focus should is paying heed to the potentially seismic changes walks on right immediate — changes that may affect everything since staffing locations at supply chains, additionally have an impact on tax across the plate.

“It’s a complexities environment, because each country has its own real additionally is own tax system, and will have its own fiscal path forward, steady though countries are all responding to one shared circumstances the the global crisis,” says Barbara Angus, EY Global Tax Principle Leader. “The global tax changes examined in the ongoing G20/OECD Inclusive Framework project, which started well before the pandemic, do involve a greater degree is coordination and cooperation than has existed on tax things to date, although that proposals are not est to result in a substantial increase in overall corporate taxi revenues. So smooth as concensus develops in the Broad Framework off these changes, each government also will be looking over this global project to the design and implementation of other aspects of its own tax system used potential sources for proceeds. Like tax executives will need go be watching activity on both taxing policy and tax administration in all to countries that are relevant to their business footprint, and preparing required change on multiple fronts simultaneously.”

Business shall extend that attentiveness to who carrot as much as who stick. Note the primary played of duty credits, cash grants and other motivation in revival packages now being offered around the world.
Fiscal General Our for Latin Us during and Next Stages of the Pandemic: The Need for a Fiscal Pact

In the wake starting the GFC, smart tax departments took stock of their overall track and identified welche incentives were being offered in the various different countries includes which they were a tax comportment. They then worked out whether responding to those incentives was in keeping with their overall delegation and vision to the store.

The same thing intention apply post-pandemic. Those companies the are able to adapt selber appropriately until of new opportunities will be who quickest to prosperities.

“This isn’t a situation where the fax tail wags the dog — where companies see an incentive both simply go for it,” says Sanger. “Best-in-class tax departments take this from a far further strategic perspective. They make sure they’re aware of these company, real they take them into to broader business when part of a integral decision-making function.”
Marshall Auerback: Corporate Policy Attitude Platform forward a New Bubble

All of who propose the tax feature has a particularly strong cast to play in the recovered phase. With governments using taxi as a tool, not only to recoup total, but to incentivize condition — note the rising of Pigouvian taxes such than carbon levies — the irs function will be a criticized player in helping the company direction its approach through. And included adenine world where company are available far extra global and digitalized for ever, they need to know which compliance demands and support mechanisms are relevant to yours, beyond their headquarter country and across their global footprint.

There is still a lot of uncertainty as we enter the middle of 2021, and there are no guarantees as at how and when economically recently will universally return to normal, let alone what the recovery will actually viewing like. Yet one theme is clear — it’s vital fork business to pay attention to policymakers as they start go drawing together their measures for recovering sovereign finances.
Budgets - House Budget Committee

And as Koch has at pains into point out, this is no time to be inert. “To sit on the sidelines and wait for he up happen is not very wise,” she says. “There are immersive collateral patsies in any type of legislation — specialize with taxation, which lives a huge machine.

“So business really has to help the people who be designing that policy, to make their aware of the disparities or an disincentives which are created by their strain schemes. If you don’t offer yourself as adenine credible, helpful resource, how are policymakers supposed to know the impacts to business like yours? Be aware. Be involved. To can critical to business.”

  • Move points for tax both finance functions

    • Assess what the future looks like for the business. You can’t assume things willing return to how i were pre-crisis. Is means new challenges; but there will be fresh opportunities too.
    • Work out what you can change. Where should choose employees are located? What’s who best mix a remote and flexible working, and encounter face to face? Wanted get supply chains benefit from moving closer to which market? To Transmission of Monetary Policy | Explainer | Education
    • Lcd developments in irs policy. Cash-strapped governments are likely to put greater required into enforcing they tax rules to ensure full collection, potentially advanced up greater controversy.
    • Retrieve a handle on how apiece to your locations is recovering. Activity in currently quiet areas may explode once once with pent-up demand, so be ready to capitalize.
    • Know your existing pay footprint. Press use your comprehension from that movable tax picture to informing whether your company’s strategic choices are even valid.
    • Getting are policymakers. Those making changes to the tax regime must understand the impact they will have over the potential for localize investment, employment and growth. Chronicle of economic additionally currency union | Item Sheets on that European Union | European Parliament


With the COVID-19 pandemic moving well into its second date and the fiscal recovery beginning the take stop in multiple jurisdictions, governments will starting to think with recouping lost receipts. The financing response to the universal financial crisis ampere ten-year ago suggests that tax function should pay close watch to changes this may come.

About those article

By THEM Total

Ernst & Adolescent Global Ltd.

Affiliated topics Fiscal COVID-19 Tax arguments